HOW TO READ · 2026-11-03
The day's guides
Method
Read Who Answers First
In a conversation, the first words of a reply tell you what the speaker thought the question was.
Most of us read dialogue in Scripture the way we read a transcript: we look for the content and skip the manner. But people in the Bible, like people anywhere, often answer a question other than the one they were asked. The first words of a reply are where this shows.
Try it with Nicodemus in John 3. He opens with a compliment and a statement: we know you are a teacher come from God. He asks nothing. Jesus replies with something that does not seem to follow at all: unless one is born again, he cannot see the kingdom. Read as a transcript, this is baffling. Read as an exchange in which Jesus answers the question under the statement, it begins to make sense. Nicodemus has come at night with a question he cannot quite say.
Or take Exodus 3, where Moses asks who he is to go to Pharaoh. God does not tell him who he is. God says, I will be with you. The reply moves the question from Moses to God, and that move is the whole answer.
The method is small. Choose a passage with a back-and-forth. With a pencil, mark the first clause of each reply, just those few words. Then ask a plain question: does this answer what was asked? Often it does, and you can move on. When it doesn't, you have found something worth a minute of your attention.
There are a few kinds of gap. Sometimes the speaker answers a fear rather than a question. Sometimes he answers the question he wishes had been asked. Sometimes, as with Jesus, the reply goes to a deeper question the other person has not yet found words for. Each kind teaches you something about the speakers, and the text rarely labels it for you.
Write one line in the margin or a notebook, no more: Moses asked who am I; God answered who I am. That sentence will do more for your memory of the passage than a page of notes.
Finally, read the exchange again straight through, with the gap in mind. You will hear the conversation as it was probably meant to be heard, as two people talking, one of whom keeps being met somewhere he did not expect.
- Pick a passage with dialogue, such as John 3 or Exodus 3.
- Underline the first clause of each reply.
- Ask whether that clause answers the question just asked.
- Write one line noting where the answer sidesteps the question.
- Read the exchange again with that gap in mind.
12 MIN
Practice
Read a Chapter, Then Wait Five Minutes
What you remember after a short silence is a better guide to the passage than anything you highlighted while reading.
Most Bible reading ends the moment the chapter does. We reach the last verse, feel a small satisfaction, and move to the next thing. What we rarely find out is what, if anything, stayed.
This practice adds a pause and a single act of retrieval. Read a chapter once, without stopping to underline or look anything up. Then close the book and let five minutes pass. Do something with your hands that asks little of your mind: dry dishes, fold a towel, stand at a window.
When the timer sounds, write down what is still there. Not a summary, and not what you think you should have noticed. Just what remains: a phrase, an image, a name, a feeling that something was strange. Three or four lines is plenty.
Then open the chapter and compare. You will probably find two things. First, that you kept less than you expected; most of us do, and there is no shame in it. Second, that what you kept is not random. The detail that stayed is often the one the writer pressed hardest, or the one that touched something in your own life. Both are worth knowing.
If you remembered the wrong thing, that helps too. Perhaps you held on to the minor character and lost the main point. Go back and see why. Sometimes the text is quietly pointing at the minor character.
This is an old idea in a plain form. Teachers have long known that recalling something strengthens it far more than reading it again. A second reading feels productive, but pulling the passage out of your own head, even clumsily, is what makes it yours.
Do this for a month with a chapter a day and keep the little notes in one place. At the end you will have a record, in your own words, of what the Bible actually left with you. It is often humbler and more interesting than what you would have claimed.
- Read one chapter once, at an ordinary pace.
- Close the Bible and set a timer for five minutes.
- Do something quiet: wash a cup, sit by a window.
- Write down what is still in your mind, in your own words.
- Open the text and compare.
Tools
A Second Copy of the Same Translation, Unmarked
A clean copy lets you read the text as if for the first time, which a marked-up Bible no longer can.
If you have read your Bible for years, it has become a record of earlier readings. The underlines, the stars, the arrows and the dated notes are all useful, and they are also a kind of instruction. They tell your eye where to go. After a while, they tell it where not to go.
A second, unmarked copy of the same translation fixes this cheaply. It does not need to be fine. A paperback or a printed set of pages will do. The only rule is that you leave it clean: no pencil, no sticky tabs, no folded corners.
Choose a book you think you know. Romans, perhaps, or Genesis, or one of the Gospels. Read it in the clean copy at a single sitting if it is short, or across a few evenings if it is not. Read as someone who has never been told what the important verses are.
What usually happens is a small surprise. Passages that your marked Bible had made famous seem smaller than expected, and verses with no mark at all stand up and ask for attention. A sentence you had underlined now appears to be part of an argument that continues past it. A story you remembered as having one point turns out to have three.
Keep a half-sheet of paper beside you and write down what you notice, not in the Bible but beside it. Page and verse, and a few words. When you finish, compare your notes to the marked copy. The distance between the two is a measure of what habit has done to your reading.
This is not a criticism of marking a Bible. The first volume in this series argued for one you can ruin, and that advice stands. It is only that every reader eventually needs a copy that has not yet decided what it means.
Keep the clean one on a shelf and bring it out once a year. Over time you may find it is the more demanding of the two, and the more honest.
- Buy or print a second copy of your usual translation.
- Keep it free of notes, underlines, and bookmarks.
- Choose one book you know well.
- Read it in the clean copy at one sitting.
- Note what the text says that your marks had hidden.
20 MIN
Back to today's paper →